The Impact of School Budget Cuts on Your Child – And You

In her first column, Dr. Lydia Soifer, director of The Soifer Center for Learning and Child Development in White Plains, discusses how this year’s school budgets may affect students in local school districts.

If you are like the parents I talk with, you are worried about the impact of school budget cuts on your child’s schooling. Districts throughout the Hudson Valley have presented budgets for next year that cut back on extracurricular activities, capital spending, salary increases, administrator jobs and, unfortunately, student services, classroom teachers and aides. In response to significant reductions in state aid to education, districts are tightening their belts, snipping, slicing or slashing everywhere they can.

The educators I work with are as concerned about this as you are. They are already under tremendous pressure to successfully educate all children in their schools. Every day, teachers build lesson plans that incorporate ever-changing content that they must deliver in new ways. They and their colleagues must deal with the dynamics of the classroom: students who want attention; those who need attention because they are struggling; students who are gifted and seeking a faster learning pace. Then there are children whose struggles can become disruptive to the classroom environment, as well as those who are barely hanging on only because they are working very hard just to keep up. 

What happens when class size increases or other forms of educational support, such as aides, pre-K, and special education services, are cut back or eliminated? Educators have less time per student to recognize and address individual needs and learning styles. It becomes more difficult to provide support to a child who is struggling. Once a child starts falling behind, it becomes harder and harder to catch up. 

So there is a conflict between the demands we place on our educational system and our willingness or ability to pay for everything we require or want. Are we headed towards or already in an educational crisis? I’m not willing to say that yet. However, I am ready to say that our educational system is creaking under the pressure of having to do more and more with less and less. 

Schools are struggling to meet the requirements of well-meaning legislators and bureaucrats. For the most part, educators are doing their best to find the most efficient and cost-effective methods for reaching the most possible children. There are bright spots, where districts are beginning to help teachers work differently with students and using new methods to reach the majority of children. Change is happening. 

At the same time, no matter how your own school district is coping with the new reality, the roles that educators play and the rules by which the system functions no longer align with our old understandings. In an era of change, where “less” is the rallying cry of legislators and taxpayers alike, how can you, as the guardian of your child’s future, ensure your child’s success?

Schools can only do, and are only willing to do, as much as they have the budget to do. Increasingly it is your role to do the heavy lifting. To be a successful advocate for your child, you need to develop an understanding of his or her educational needs. Learn what a school is legally and financially obligated to provide under what circumstances, and be prepared to ask for changes. Be ready to draw on all resources available—within and outside of the educational system.

Most of all, if your child is struggling at all, do not indulge in “magical thinking.”  My best advice is to be proactive and smart about your child’s needs. Start by working within your school’s system for extra support. Be persistent in getting updates and asking for tangible measures of progress. For many children, this help is enough, but some children need more intensive services. To have the best chance at success, I always recommend that parents seek the help most effective for their child.  

Isn’t it ironic? Like your child (and on their behalf), you have to work hard and do your homework. After all, failure is not an option. 

Dr. Soifer, director of The Soifer Center for Learning and Child Development in White Plains, has been called “Teacher of Teachers and Friend of Kids.”  For more than 35 years, she has helped parents, children, educators and physicians to understand learning, behavior, communication and the nature of language functioning in academic performance and success. Her column will be published twice a month.

Glenn J. DeFaber April 11, 2011 at 10:30 PM
It is simply amazing how “experts” are bemoaning the impact on education due to budget cuts. If money was the answer to better education how do they explain the steady decline in student performance relative to the rest of the world? Up until 2008 education funding was beyond rational thinking. If there was a school budget vote with a 5% tax increase the taxpayers were very lucky. Now that the well is dry people are looking around for people to blame. I guess all the experts have thrown out their mirror.
Dr John April 12, 2011 at 05:48 PM
"cut back on extracurricular activities, capital spending, salary increases, administrator jobs " Does anyone see this happening in Harrison. We have a school budget almost 2x what our town budget is. %3 million dollar budget for the town to manage 26,000 residents and 105 millin dollares to educatio 3,500 students. Something is wrong here. I agree with Glenn DeFaber.
Michael LaDore April 13, 2011 at 12:05 AM
There's a great story I read about awhile ago that shows that as a whole, our school system (statewide/nationwide) has lost touch with reality....and I agree with Glen DeFaber & Dr John. So here goes, (its not my story-& I don't know the author) One day, a rabbit, a squirrel, a fish and an eel got together and decided to start a school. The bird wanted flying to be part of the curriculum. The fish insisted that swimming be part of the program and the squirrel wanted tree climbing, so they put all these things into the program and insisted that everyone take part in every activity. While the rabbit got an A in running, whenever he tried to climb a tree he had a problem and he kept falling and pretty soon he got hurt so bad he couldn't even run any more. He found that instead of making an A in running, he was making a C and worst of all, he always made an F in climbing. Meanwhile the bird was great at flying, but when it came to burrowing in the ground like the squirrel, he was no good. He kept breaking his beak and wings. Now he was making a C in flying and an F in Burrowing and you can forget about tree climbing!. For the fish, need I go further??? The moral of the story is that the valedictorian of the class was the eel who did everything in a half way fashion, but the educators were all happy because everyone was taking all the subjects (It was called a broad based education!) We are all different and lets deal with that!
grassroots April 13, 2011 at 03:16 PM
I think it's commom knowlege that more money does not = better education at this point in history.Public education has become a giant political machine with the UFT behind the controls.We need good old compitition at this point.Most charter schools have proven themselves to be a better deal for the buck.Our schools need fewer days off. Increase the school year thats half the problem.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »