.

Plastic Bags to Go the Way of the Dinosaurs in Larchmont

Larchmont will be the third Westchester community to successfully ban plastic bags.

 

Though their usage is frequently short-lived, plastic T-shirt bags often have a second life floating in bodies of water, dangling from treetops or strewn on the side of the road, a reminder that the bags will outlive their usefulness into eternity as litter that overwhelms the environment.

But in waterfront communities, the presence of the flimsy bags can have a more serious effect. By blowing into oceans or rivers, they are lethal to the fish and marine animals that consume them. Their presence in catch basins blocks their ability to catch runoff, causing flooding.

According to statistics from the Larchmont Committee on the Environment, 100 billion plastic bags are thrown away every year in the U.S., the equivalent of dumping nearly 12 billion oil barrels.  Fewer than 10 percent are recycled. According to New York State law, any facility over 10,000 square feet has to have a plastic bag recycling receptacle.

Communities across the country have already banned plastic bags, including Los Angeles; San Francisco; Brownsville, TX; Chestertown, MD; the entire state of Hawaii; Southampton and East Hampton, NY and Westport, CT.  In Westchester County, both Rye and the Village of Mamaroneck (VOM) have passed bans, and the Town of Mamaroneck discussed the possibility last summer (They will reopen the discussion at a public hearing on April 3 at 8 p.m.). The VOM ban will go into effect on April 1.

And now the Village of Larchmont will become the third Sound Shore community to officially ban the abhorrent and non-biodegradable bags. The bag ban was approved at Tuesday's board of trustee's meeting.

Elizabeth Poyet, a member of Committee on the Environment for the Village of Larchmont, said that the Committee became interested in the cause in 2011 and invited Sara Goddard—a member of Rye’s Sustainability Committee who spearheaded the Rye plastic bag ban—to speak to them about Rye’s success with the ban.

“Many bags blow out to sea where they end up swirling around indefinitely in one of the five gigantic ocean garbage patches,” said Poyet.

Pulling out her own reusable bag—which was purchased on a trip to Paris for $1.20—Poyet said the experience was, “An ah-ha moment for me.”

With the help of a committee member, Poyet modeled several reusable bags that have been given out by Larchmont merchants with purchases.

“Walking around with one of these, instead of three or four plastic bags, is cool, it’s chic and it’s a sign of good stewardship and it says ‘I believe in the future,’” she said.

Jonathan Cunitz, a member of the Westport Connecticut Town Meeting and an author and co-sponsor of the 2009 Westport ban, said that the law received extensive support from both residents and local merchants. The Westport law has been used as a model for VOM, Rye, Southampton, East Hampton and Chestertown bans.

“The ordinance is a non-issue; it has resulted in the elimination of plastic bags from the environment and created an environmental awareness that has sparked other environmental initiatives such as the town-wide cleanup to celebrate Earth Day,” he said.

Cunitz said that a smoother transition could be achieved if retailers posted signs reminding shoppers of the new ban; had reusable bags available for purchase; and trained cashiers to ask customers with only a few items if they even wanted a bag.

Morgan Stein, a member of the Mamaroneck High School Environmental Club, noted the large number of bags that ended up in local waters or on school grounds.

“I think if we ban plastic bags we’ll send a large message to teenagers in this community that we care about the environment and care about youth,” she said.

Critics of reusable bags have cited studies that show E. coli and coliform bacteria growth as prevalent in bags that are frequently utilized. 

The solution is simple though, says Goddard, who recommended keeping several bags and throwing them in the wash after each use.

Goddard said that ban in Rye has had no negative effect on local businesses.

“It’s a small change that yields enormous environmental benefits,” she said.

One Larchmont business owner, Bill Homer, of , is ahead of the curve: he's been utilizing reusable bags since his shop opened in 2009.  A lifelong surfer, he said his decision was informed not only by his concern for polluted waters and marine life, but, as the father of four daughters, less pollution for future generations.

“It has not put us out of business,” he said.

As the board unanimously voted to pass the local law, thunderous applause and cheering was heard from supporters in the audience.

The law will take effect in six months—on Oct. 1, 2013—and prevents any retail establishment from distributing bags, other than those defined as recyclable and/or reusable, to customers at the point of sale.  Thin produce bags used for deli meats or other items, dry cleaning bags, bags sized 28” by 36” or larger, newspaper delivery bags, Ziploc bags and restaurant bags meant to prevent spillage of food are all excluded from the ban.  The penalty for each violation will be up to $150.

Editor's Note: An earlier version of this article mistakenly referred to a speaker from MHS as Jennifer Morgenstein; her name is Morgan Stein. Also, the word "garbage" was emitted from a quote from Elizabeth Poyet.  Patch apologizes for the errors.

BG7 March 21, 2013 at 01:26 PM
Paper bags work fine too, like they hand out at Trader Joe's. Still better than making the plastic bag garbage patch bigger and bigger. The Mamaroneck river all the way down to the harbor has trees decorated with old plastic bags. On that note - whats with all the foam bubbles in the Sheldrake river recently? Pollution galore.
Buddy March 21, 2013 at 03:01 PM
I'm glad to see this is finally happening! Town of Mamaroneck should follow suit on this.
Jeanne March 21, 2013 at 11:36 PM
I'm as much of a tree-hugger as the next person, but if I buy raw meat in a store, I want it in a plastic bag that separates it from my other groceries. Ditto for the oil-drenched olives/peppers I buy at grocery stores, whose containers always manage to leak. I am a responsible person when it comes to recycling, but I won't be shopping at these stores any more if it's just going to make a mess on the way home.
april marie March 22, 2013 at 12:19 AM
What does one use to pick up and dispose of dog poop?
Stefani Kim March 22, 2013 at 01:54 AM
Hi Jeanne, Thin produce bags used to protect other food from dripping meat or hold fruits/vegetables are excluded from the plastic bag ban. Best, Stefani
Elizabeth Poyet March 22, 2013 at 04:31 AM
You can use any of the plastic bags that will still be permitted: plastic bags to protect newspapers, bread bags, produce bags from the grocery or deli, etc. You can also purchase rolls of bags sold specially for this purpose.
Billy L March 22, 2013 at 02:41 PM
This is all well and good but what about that article I read a few years ago where the reusable bags were found to have lead in them? http://tucsoncitizen.com/wryheat/2013/03/21/tucsons-plastic-bag-brouhaha-and-a-stupid-study-imposed-by-the-city-council/
Gerry Collins March 22, 2013 at 05:57 PM
Wonderful! Great example for other communities!!
Leslie Yager March 22, 2013 at 07:17 PM
I'm curious what will happen with the papers like New York Times and WSJ that are still delivered inside plastic bag "sleeves." (I use those when I walk my dogs.) Curious, but I think the ban is great and would like to see it in Greenwich.
SRT March 23, 2013 at 03:14 PM
Are they pellets? There was a accident at a plastic manufacturer in the industrial section a week or two ago. They might be related to that.
Paula March 24, 2013 at 11:01 AM
I only wish that there could be a feeling of responsibility of people in general. If people could bring their reusable bags, but have use of the store's plastic ones when needed. I personally would do best with using my reusable bags sometimes, but have some plasitic bags. For years, I have cut the use of plastic by having kitchen garbage cans that are specially designed to hold the store plastic bags. That save me (and the environment) form needing the tall kitchen bags that most people, including eco-sensitive people buy. My big garbage can that I set on the curb gets filled with the grocery plastic bags filled with our kitchen waste, so I also don't need to buy the big black garbage bags to hold it all. Both the tall kitchen nags and black garbage bags are of a much heavier weight. This is coming from a person who was ahead of this issue years ago when I moved to White Plains and got on the bad side of the Journal news editor for making an issue of how they don't need to double-bag their paper while publishing stories about plastic waste and polution. I clean newspaper bags (all publications) from my bridge on the Mamaroenck River and there is no end in sight. The solution that the White Plains Planning Board has come up with is to listen to a spec builder's requests to remove the bridge, which is in effect like flushing a toilet to Mamaroneck and the Long Island Sound.
Paula March 24, 2013 at 11:07 AM
How many people who are so proud of pushing this through are now going to proudly carry their eco-reusable bags to the grocery store and while there are going to buy a box of tall kiltchen bags of a heavier hage than the store bags, and buy the big black garbage bags to put in their town-issued giant garbage cans and then put their boxes of bags inside their eco-reusable shopping bag and take them home? This is on top of the fact that we are going to end up putting our garbage into the big town-issued barbage cans after we had to throw out the old plastic garbage cans we used for years, since no towns I know of can figure out how to recycle the plastic garbage cans we all used to have in our driveway? By the way, the special kitchen garbage can that uses grocery store plastic bags I bought about 5 years ago came from the Container Store and they still sell them. they aren't expensive and hold up well.
Catherine Wachs March 28, 2013 at 07:11 PM
BG7, leaves, twigs and other organic substances fall into water and decay, which releases compounds known as surfacants. This interaction breaks the surface tension, which allows air to more easily mix with water and creates bubbles. This is natural and frequent in moving water. But not all foam is natural. Detergents can cause foam that is similar in appearance but is harmful to fish and other aquatic life. Too much surficant destroys the surface tension, essential for some insects to breed (good AND bad bugs). And antibacterial soap is the worst. It doesn't clean any better than hot water and a light soaping.
Catherine Wachs March 28, 2013 at 07:22 PM
All plastic would be hard to eliminate, Paula, agreed. But the grocery bags are especially onerous. They can be seen caught on branches and tons are in the marshes. Plus, the baggers put in 3 items and double it, so that is a wasteful practice. Plastic is made from oil, a non-renewable resource. I reuse bread bags 1x for meat, but also have a washable bag for that purpose. I have cleaned up many, many plastic bags and bottles for the Coastal Cleanups in September. Both are a stain on the environment. I only use 1 garbage liner in the can for the bathroom. Many times it doesn't need to be changed, depending on the garbage that week. Every action creates a string of either good outcomes or bad. We all must strive to use as little plastic as possible. It may seem like a losing proposition, the problem is so big. But McDonalds sold a billion hamburgers, one at a time. You do make a difference.
J.M March 29, 2013 at 08:57 PM
Newspaper bags work just fine for most dogs. For example, I have a Labrador Retriever, and those bags are just fine. They're also made of a different type of plastic, I believe, so they're easier to get rid of.
J.M March 29, 2013 at 08:59 PM
Than use paper or canvas bags. Paper can be recycled with newspapers, and canvas bags have multiple uses besides carrying groceries.

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something